Initial Thoughts On The First Debate

Obama appears to have gone into the debate  looking to protect his lead and take no chances. As a result he came off too wonkish. He responded to some Romney lies but allowed many  others to go unchallenged. Romney better understood how these “debates” work in ignoring the actual questions and ignoring the facts. The debates are not about actually answering questions or about giving the most scholarly answer. Romney will be awarded the win by the pundits, but it is doubtful anything he said will really convince many people to vote for him. John Kerry beat George Bush far more decisively than Romney won tonight but still lost the election.

On taxes, Mitt Romney decided to shake the Etch-A-Sketch and ignore everything he has supported to date. While Romney has told many lies, he was at the most dishonest on health care. Obama did a fair job of responding to Romney’s lies about a board which will be making health care decisions but Obama failed to respond to Romney’s distortions about Medicare cuts.

Romney was the far better bullshitter while Obama was the one up on stage who was able to give serious answers. Unfortunately the television debate format is not a good place for such professorial explanations. I am tempted to say that this was the most boring debate I have watched but realistically if there were boring ones in the past I wouldn’t recall them for comparison. I was waiting for them to debate which state has the trees which are the right height or whether planes should have windows. I am now worried that Romney plans to tie Big  Bird to the top of his car.

Obama generally had the wrong strategy for this debate, but at times did effectively challenge Romney, such as in asking for specifics of which deductions Romney would cut. My bet is that Obama will take on Romney more forcibly in the next two debates.

The post-debate coverage is often more important in influencing opinion than the actual debate.  Romney won the debate on style but as the fact checkers are looking at the debate Romney is losing points. Further discussion of topics such as Romney’s tax plan, the actual facts about Medicare, and health-care reform could wind up benefit ting Obama more than Romney.

Update: Or, as wound up happening, the media could concentrate on simplistic stories about who won (based upon style) and ignore the issues.


  1. 1
    Eric Ferguson says:

    Initial Thoughts On The First Debate–Romney wins on style, loses on facts #p2 #p21 #topprog

  2. 2
    Bad Wolf says:

    My wife is about as non-political as you can get.  She deliberately avoids any kind of political speech, or virtually anything to do with politics. Last night was the first time she saw Romney in any kind of televised setting.  After about 45 seconds, she told me, “OK, I’ll vote for Obama, This guy (Romney) is creepy.”
    Later she said that he reminded her of Jim Jones, and that he sacred her. 

    Politics.  From Greek
    Poly = many
    Tics = small annoying bloodsucking parasites

    If the opposite of “Pro” is “Con”, what’s the opposite of “Progress”? 

  3. 3
    John Sonntag says:

    RT @ronchusid: Initial Thoughts On The First Debate #p2 #p21 #topprog

  4. 4
    David K. Sutton says:

    RT @ronchusid: Initial Thoughts On The First Debate #p2 #p21 #topprog

1 Trackbacks

Leave a comment